The theory tracker

Seven scientific theories of consciousness, four wider positions, and how each is holding up now that the theories are being tested against each other in public.

Last reviewed November 3, 2026 · Updated when results land

Current oddsEditorial · last changed November 2026

How to read this. Odds are our editors’ confidence that a theory is closest to right, not a market. Changelog. Nov 2026: Dendritic Integration (4%) and Orch-OR (1%) added to the board, others scaled to make room; preliminary NYU results nudge RPT down. Apr 2025: COGITATE 1 published, IIT 28 to 22, GNWT 26 to 20, predictive processing 16 to 18.

01The contenders

The claim, the boldest prediction, the best criticism

Also in the argument

Philosophical positions and minority hypotheses

02The scoreboard

Every head-to-head test so far · tap any cell
HitMissPartialPendingNot tested

03The tests

Where the results come from · status as of Nov 2026

04The big questions

Where each theory lands

The theories disagree about more than brain regions. Their answers decide whether your chatbot could feel anything, which animals count, and what doctors owe a patient who can’t respond.

Simplified. Each theory’s answer is how its main proponents would put it today; individual researchers disagree.

05The inner side

Meditation and psychedelics in the argument

The theories are mostly built from lab perception tasks and patients. The states that people who meditate or take psychedelics report are starting to become evidence too.

Psychedelics · predictive processing

Relaxed beliefs

Carhart-Harris and Friston’s REBUS model says psychedelics loosen the brain’s highest-level predictions, so bottom-up signals get more say. It’s the clearest case of a consciousness theory making claims about altered states, and much psychedelic research is now framed in its terms.

Carhart-Harris & Friston, Pharmacological Reviews 2019 ↗
Meditation · active inference

A beautiful loop

Ruben Laukkonen, Karl Friston and Shamil Chandaria propose that consciousness arises when a predictive model includes a model of its own knowing, and use meditative states, including the fading of the sense of self, as test cases.

Laukkonen, Friston & Chandaria, Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2025 ↗
Meditation · all theories

When awareness stops

Advanced meditators describe “cessations,” moments where experience seems to switch off and come back. A Harvard-affiliated team has recorded them with EEG in an intensively studied expert. Any theory has to say what changed in those seconds.

Chowdhury et al., Neuropsychologia 2023 ↗
The field’s own prescription

More first-person data

In 2025, Cleeremans, Mudrik and Seth reviewed the state of the field and called for more phenomenology, careful descriptions of what experience is like, alongside tougher, theory-driven tests.

Cleeremans, Mudrik & Seth, Frontiers in Science 2025 ↗

06Timeline

1988 to now
Theory bornTest or eventResultScroll sideways →

07The fights

Both sides, on the record
September 2023 · April 2025

The pseudoscience letter

124 researchers signed an open letter calling integrated information theory pseudoscience, arguing its core claims are untestable and its implications too far-reaching. In April 2025 Nature Neuroscience ran all three sides in one issue: the critics, the IIT group’s reply, and a comment from Gómez-Marin and Seth calling the charge unwarranted.

The chargeIIT's predictions can't be falsified in practice; calling it a leading theory misleads the public.
The replyCogitate tested IIT's predictions and some failed, which is what a scientific theory looks like. The letter was about taste, not evidence.
June 2023 · New York

The bet

In 1998 Christof Koch bet David Chalmers a case of wine that the neural correlates of consciousness would be found within 25 years. At the 2023 ASSC meeting, Koch conceded and handed over the wine. He immediately proposed a new bet for 2048.

What it settledNothing scientific. It marked how far the field still is from a mechanism.
Why it mattersTwo of the field's leaders agree the hard problem is not close to solved.
2017 · Journal of Neuroscience

Front or back?

Two back-to-back papers argued over where consciousness lives. Boly, Koch, Tononi and others made the case for the posterior cortex. Odegaard, Knight, and Lau argued the prefrontal cortex is required and the lesion evidence has been misread.

Posterior campIIT, recurrent processing. Patients with frontal damage stay conscious.
Frontal campGNWT, higher-order theories. Frontal decoding and metacognition data.
April 2025 · Nature

COGITATE 1

The first large adversarial collaboration: seven labs, 256 participants, three recording methods, predictions registered in advance by IIT and GNWT. The consortium’s summary: the results fit some predictions of each theory and substantially challenged key tenets of both. Hakwan Lau, who reviewed it for Nature, argued the design didn’t put either theory to a real test.

IIT afterPosterior content yes; sustained synchrony no.
GNWT afterPrefrontal content weak; no ignition at stimulus offset.

08What to watch

Results that could move the odds
  1. COGITATE 2. The video-game experiment’s results paper. A second shot at IIT vs GNWT with attention manipulated directly.
  2. NYU imaging. Whether the brain data back the early behavioral lean toward higher-order theories over recurrent processing.
  3. INTREPID. The first test that pits IIT against predictive theories, with Friston and Tononi both at the table.
  4. ETHOS. Which version of higher-order theory survives contact with its rivals inside the family.
  5. IIT vs GNWT in animals. An Allen Institute-led test in animal brains, running since 2021 with no results yet.
Koch and Chalmers bet a case of wine. You bet your pride.

Place your bet

Which theory is closest to right? Pick one, see how your call compares with our editors’ odds, and cast your vote. We’ll publish what readers think.

Pick a theory to see our odds.

09Go deeper

Across ACC/IN
Research

Every consciousness-science paper

The consciousness science room: the theories, the adversarial tests, hidden awareness in patients. Peer-reviewed, last ten years.

Enter the room →
Ask the research

Which theory has the best evidence?

Our AI answers only from peer-reviewed papers in the library and cites every claim.

Ask it →
Library

Books, talks and podcasts

Start with the people behind these theories, or ask the Guide where you should begin.

Open the library →

10Sources

Proponents in their own words, then their critics

Researchers: if we’ve mischaracterized your view, tell us and we’ll correct it.